Shadow Presets (Feedback Needed)

I need your help! I'm trying to figure out what the best (fastest and easiest) approach is for the shadow panel for my web app Webflow.

TOP OPTION: You can only create a shadow by selecting a preset (drop shadow, inner shadow, outer glow, inner-highlight). This is how photoshop/illustrator does it. Even if you you start with a preset you can arent restricted to change any setting of the shadow.

BOTTOM OPTION: You create a shadow by pressing + which will create a basic shadow (like the first preset above) or you can choose a preset from the drop down.

Which one is most straightforward for you? Thanks!!