Sonoran Yogi Logo Options

Presenting this to a client for a personal social media brand, wonder which one he will pick. The first one plays off the Arizona saguaro cactus with the elongated 'S' and 'Y' as arms. While the bottom one is prickly, almost static looking - mimicking a cactus without too much flare. Based on his direction, I am interested to see which one he prefers. Clean and legible, but with character.