Rate My Kills

Would love to hear some feedback/criticism over these three logos that I have put together for a web project I'm involved in.

Let's hear what you all have to say everyone!

A little background on the project, this is a viral marketing site for an arrow head manufacturer. They want to expand their customer base in the hunting industry. Their idea is to create a site for hunters to upload their "kills" and have fellow hunters rate them on a scale of 1-10... This is the logo for that. Interface design to come soon.