Church Cool

We're designing a mark for an awesome church client. They are focused on appealing to guys in their mid-thirties who may not have been open to attending a church before. The Dribbble community represents their target audience, so we want to see what you think about these marks any why one or the other stands out to you.

Both marks are rich with storytelling around their mission and approach, so we're trying to decide on design merit alone. Help us out! Which resonates more with you, left or right?