Editor's Choice Badges

I'm working for a magazine now (Taste for Life) and we're starting a new feature where our lead editor chooses and writes about her favorite natural products each month. They asked for a badge or icon that could be used in the monthly column and also on advertisements from the product manufacturers in ours and other publications. These are my initial thoughts/submissions. Nothing crazy just some clear, simple badges. They will be fine-tuned and color will be added once we get some feedback going.

Thoughts, comments, criticism welcome.