Best players not in the Hall of Fame

A friend is running his annual project where readers of his site vote for the 50 best players outside of the Hall of Fame. I've been thinking of contributing some sort of chart this year. Took a quick stab at something tonight.

NE: Not eligible
NR: Eligible, but not ranked

I'm not giving away the results for this year (I haven't seen them yet). Just using the 2012 data in the 2013 column.